HUB 01 · Chef Knives
MAC vs Shun
Two excellent hard Japanese knives with opposite personalities: the plain cult favorite that just cuts, and the Damascus beauty you display.
We earn a commission when you buy through our Amazon links, at no extra cost to you. It never changes a ranking, and we say so when the cheaper knife is the better buy. How this works.
The MAC MTH-80 and the Shun Classic are both hard, keen Japanese knives that serious cooks respect — but they sell to different instincts. The MAC is the plain, thin workhorse the pros quietly recommend to each other; the Shun is the Damascus showpiece you display on a magnetic strip. Both cut beautifully. The choice is really about what you value past the edge.
The differences that matter
| Trait | MAC MTH-80 | Shun Classic |
|---|---|---|
| Steel / hardness | Molybdenum-vanadium, ~HRC 59–61 | VG-MAX Damascus, ~HRC 60–61 |
| Edge | ~15° per side, dimpled | 16° per side |
| Weight | ~6.5 oz, very thin | ~7.5 oz |
| Handle | Symmetric Pakkawood | D-shaped (right-handed) |
| Looks | Plain, utilitarian | Damascus showpiece |
How they differ in the hand
The MAC is unusually thin, so it falls through produce with almost no wedging, and its granton dimples reduce sticking — it's our top overall pick in the flagship ranking for pure cutting-per-dollar. Its symmetric handle suits left and right hands. The Shun cuts nearly as well and adds real finish — genuine 68-layer Damascus and a locking D-handle — for a premium, but that handle is right-handed. Both are hard enough to chip if abused; treat either with care.
How to choose
Buy the MACif you want the best cutter for the money and don't care what it looks like — it's the cook's choice, and it's left-hand friendly. Buy the Shunif you want a knife that's a pleasure to look atas well as use, you're right-handed, and the Damascus matters to you — it's our gift and showpiece pick. On value the MAC wins; on beauty the Shun does. Neither is a mistake.
Questions
Frequently asked
Is the MAC MTH-80 better than the Shun Classic?
For pure cutting-per-dollar, the MAC — it's thinner, plainer and a bit cheaper, and it's left-hand friendly. The Shun cuts nearly as well and adds real Damascus finish and a locking D-handle for a premium, but that handle is right-handed. Buy the MAC for performance, the Shun for beauty.
Which holds an edge longer, MAC or Shun?
About the same — both are hard Japanese steels around HRC 60, so both hold an edge far longer than a German knife and both can chip if abused. The difference is finish and handle, not edge life.
Is the MAC or Shun better for left-handers?
The MAC — its symmetric Pakkawood handle works in either hand. The standard Shun Classic's D-handle is built for right-handers, so lefties should prefer the MAC (or Shun's rarer left-handed model).
Keep reading