HUB 01 · Chef Knives
Tojiro vs MAC
Two hard, thin, keen Japanese blades that experienced cooks swear by — one a clad VG-10 gyuto, the other the quiet moly-vanadium favorite. A close call decided by feel and finish.
We earn a commission when you buy through our Amazon links, at no extra cost to you. It never changes a ranking, and we say so when the cheaper knife is the better buy. How this works.
The Tojiro DP and the MAC MTH-80are two of the best-loved value-to-mid Japanese chef's knives, and cross-shoppers agonize over them for good reason: both are thin, hard and keen, and both punch well above their price. The differences are real but subtle — steel type, finish and handle feel more than raw capability.
The differences that matter
| Trait | Tojiro DP 8.3" | MAC MTH-80 |
|---|---|---|
| Steel / hardness | VG-10 core, clad, ~HRC 60 | Molybdenum-vanadium, ~HRC 59–61 |
| Edge angle | ~15° per side | ~15° per side |
| Construction | Stamped, bolsterless, riveted handle | Thin stamped, no bolster, dimpled |
| Weight / feel | ~7.4 oz, planted for a Japanese knife | ~6.5 oz, light and precise |
| Fit and finish | Value-grade (functional edges/spine) | More refined out of the box |
| Price bracket | Value ($70–90 range) | Mid ($100+ range) |
Steel and cutting: a near-tie
Both run around HRC 60, both are ground thin, and both take and hold a keener edge than any German knife here. The Tojiro's VG-10 coreis a hair harder and slightly more wear-resistant; the MAC's molybdenum-vanadium steel is famous for taking a screaming edge and being a touch more forgiving to sharpen. In the kitchen the cutting difference is small — both are excellent thin cutters that reward a whetstone and good technique.
Finish and feel: where the MAC earns its premium
The gap shows in refinement. The MAC arrives more polished — smoother spine and choil, a slightly nicer factory edge, a lighter and more nimble balance. The Tojiro is a value knife and shows it: the edges of the spine can be sharp out of the box (a quick pass with sandpaper fixes it), the finish is plainer, and it feels a little more blade-heavy. For the money the Tojiro is a phenomenal cutter with unglamorous fittings; the MAC costs more for a better-finished, more comfortable knife around the same edge.
How to choose
Buy the Tojiroif you want the most Japanese cutting performance per dollar and you don't mind rougher fittings — it's a superb, honest value blade. Buy the MACif you want a more refined, lighter, better- finished knife around the same edge and you'll keep it for years. Both live in best Japanese chef knives, and both, being hard, want a stone rather than a pull- through. Comparing against German options too? See MAC vs Wüsthof.
Questions
Frequently asked
Tojiro DP or MAC MTH-80 — which is better?
They're very close cutters — both hard, thin and keen around HRC 60. The Tojiro gives you more performance per dollar with plainer fittings; the MAC costs more for a lighter, more refined, better-finished knife around the same edge. Choose on budget and feel.
Is the Tojiro's spine really sharp out of the box?
It can be — value Japanese knives often ship with square, unrounded spine and choil edges that press into a pinch grip. It's a two-minute fix with fine sandpaper and doesn't affect cutting. The MAC generally arrives more polished in this respect.
Do both need a whetstone?
Yes — both are hard Japanese steel and are best maintained on a whetstone. Avoid pull-through sharpeners, which tear a coarse edge and can chip hard blades. A honing rod does little for steel this hard.
Keep reading